404 Media has obtained a cache of internal police emails showing at least two agencies have bought access to GeoSpy, an AI tool that analyzes architecture, soil, and other features to near instantly geolocate photos.
Like ‘this kind of rock formation only appears in Eastern Europe, the wheel you see in the lower left of the screen has Cyrillic writing and if you look in eastern Europe there is one mountain formation that looks like the picture when viewed from a specific angle and so they had to be within this 50m circle’.
In addition, any organization that’s using this at scale will also have human experts to handle the edge cases and to validate the system’s findings.
We can’t copy the human expert without years of training, but copying a program/computer system is only a few terminal commands. The ability to do this kind of thing at scale is entirely new.
It’s not hard. I once saw a random “what is this thing” photo from a bad angle. But it included a store in the background. Only two stores in North America with that name, though Google map search tried to be helpful and return a bunch of other results. Easy enough to check both.
Even with the extra street view angles I couldn’t figure out what the thing was though :(
It’s one of those tasks where it has a bunch of little components, each of which is easy to do (like identifying a store, or mineral formation, or road signs, etc) and so it is a thing that you can design machine learning tools around the individual tasks (‘what is this rock?’) and then instead of needing a highly trained human being to take a few minutes/hours to go through all of the details from memory, you can just push thousands of pictures through an AI system and get ‘good enough’ results.
It seems like there is a company selling such a ‘good enough’ service.
Is it just reading metadata and pretending it’s doing something impressive?
It’s doing what the Geo Guesser-like people do.
Like ‘this kind of rock formation only appears in Eastern Europe, the wheel you see in the lower left of the screen has Cyrillic writing and if you look in eastern Europe there is one mountain formation that looks like the picture when viewed from a specific angle and so they had to be within this 50m circle’.
Download some pictures and ask ChatGPT thinking to find the locations.
It’s already trained on geoguesser data, even if that wasn’t a core feature.
This is the kind of thing that machine learning is very very good at. Its never going to be perfect but its definitely gonna outperform humans.
In addition, any organization that’s using this at scale will also have human experts to handle the edge cases and to validate the system’s findings.
We can’t copy the human expert without years of training, but copying a program/computer system is only a few terminal commands. The ability to do this kind of thing at scale is entirely new.
It’s not hard. I once saw a random “what is this thing” photo from a bad angle. But it included a store in the background. Only two stores in North America with that name, though Google map search tried to be helpful and return a bunch of other results. Easy enough to check both.
Even with the extra street view angles I couldn’t figure out what the thing was though :(
It’s one of those tasks where it has a bunch of little components, each of which is easy to do (like identifying a store, or mineral formation, or road signs, etc) and so it is a thing that you can design machine learning tools around the individual tasks (‘what is this rock?’) and then instead of needing a highly trained human being to take a few minutes/hours to go through all of the details from memory, you can just push thousands of pictures through an AI system and get ‘good enough’ results.
It seems like there is a company selling such a ‘good enough’ service.