I am often in the comments of threads like this trying to explain how things people don’t fully understand are in fact complicated.
Nope.
Not here.
Sue Valve over this, I hope they lose.
Yeah I dunno if currently existing law is or isn’t sufficient to actually render a guilty verdict here…
… but I hope it is.
Lootboxes are bullshit, Valve does a lot of good, but this ain’t that.
Stole mom’s credit card to buy CS2 gun skins?
Yeah, if you wanna make the argument that a credit card is sufficient to screen if somebody is an adult or not, might be a good idea to, you know, not allow kids to gamble with mom’s credit card.
On one hand: I just want my Steam Frame so I can put a real, actual computer on my face and escape into it and dev on it, dammit. I bet the gambling allows them to take risks like that.
… On the other hand… illegalizing loot boxes might directly put us on the path to Half-Life 3 or even Left 4 Dead 3? And it’s morally upstanding so…
It’s actually a bummer that if they lose it’ll probably just make them cut access to loot boxes SPECIFICALLY in NYC IP address ranges and nothing else.
Well of course, the court to determine Valves lootbox + key paradigm is illegal
Pay a fine to the state
Resitution to all NY residents
So, even if it did only apply to NY… you would at least be due to have all your key purchases refunded, as welp as the amount that Valve shaves off of every item transaction in the marketplace.
I am often in the comments of threads like this trying to explain how things people don’t fully understand are in fact complicated.
Nope.
Not here.
Sue Valve over this, I hope they lose.
Yeah I dunno if currently existing law is or isn’t sufficient to actually render a guilty verdict here…
… but I hope it is.
Lootboxes are bullshit, Valve does a lot of good, but this ain’t that.
Stole mom’s credit card to buy CS2 gun skins?
Yeah, if you wanna make the argument that a credit card is sufficient to screen if somebody is an adult or not, might be a good idea to, you know, not allow kids to gamble with mom’s credit card.
Full NY AG press release:
https://ag.ny.gov/press-release/2026/attorney-general-james-sues-game-developer-promoting-illegal-gambling-through
The actual lawsuit filing:
https://ag.ny.gov/sites/default/files/court-filings/new-york-v-valve-corporation-complaint-2026.pdf
I’m the first guy to go to bat to point out why someone’s bullshit issue with valve is bullshit.
But this ain’t one of those times. Valve is as guilty as all the others on this. Loot boxes should be illegal. And valve should be ashamed.
On one hand: I just want my Steam Frame so I can put a real, actual computer on my face and escape into it and dev on it, dammit. I bet the gambling allows them to take risks like that.
… On the other hand… illegalizing loot boxes might directly put us on the path to Half-Life 3 or even Left 4 Dead 3? And it’s morally upstanding so…
It’s actually a bummer that if they lose it’ll probably just make them cut access to loot boxes SPECIFICALLY in NYC IP address ranges and nothing else.
Well, if you read the lawsuit, NY is seeking:
Well of course, the court to determine Valves lootbox + key paradigm is illegal
Pay a fine to the state
Resitution to all NY residents
So, even if it did only apply to NY… you would at least be due to have all your key purchases refunded, as welp as the amount that Valve shaves off of every item transaction in the marketplace.