Gotta love a shitty repub SCOTUS. Its awesome.
The case is in US District Court for the Northern District of Texas, so appeals would be heard in the US Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit—which is generally regarded as one of the most conservative appeals courts in the country.
In April, the FTC issued a rule that would render the vast majority of current noncompete clauses unenforceable and ban future ones. The agency said that noncompete clauses are “an unfair method of competition and therefore a violation of Section 5 of the FTC Act,”
…
“The issue presented is whether the FTC’s ability to promulgate rules concerning unfair methods of competition include the authority to create substantive rules regarding unfair methods of competition,” Brown, a Trump appointee, wrote.
Brown acknowledged that “the FTC has some authority to promulgate rules to preclude unfair methods of competition.” But “the text, structure, and history of the FTC Act reveal that the FTC lacks substantive rulemaking authority with respect to unfair methods of competition under Section 6(g),” she wrote.
“Traditionally the FTC has been a wet noodle. Seeking to actually fix anything would be overstepping their bounds.”
Am I reading that right?
Removed by mod
I would just get a cat. Usually they fix them for free at the shelter. I mean you can fix a judge, don’t get me wrong. But you probably don’t want to do it cuz it’s messy, and they don’t like it! I haven’t seen one judge yet say how good getting fixed was. Not one.
Here’s the great thing, their dislike is a feature not a bug!
Court System needs to be revamped and public elections held pronto, having respective districts elect Judges by the people instead of politicians.
Elected judges just make the dangers of populist factions like fascist even worse. That’d be a neat sighted decision.
Judges are meant to represent the people. They are meant to represent the laws enacted by them.
Federalist Society member, nominated by Trump.
Lina Khan looking fierce in that thumbnail. That’s what I’m voting for in November.
One of the highlights of the Biden admin, definitely.
That thumbnail of Lina Khan perfectly encapsulates how I’m feeling about the government lately.
What Republicans hate about China is their big lead on the human rights abuse game… They’re trying to catch up.
Yet another reason why I’m willing to pay out the ass to live in California. If I become an expert in a technology field, and leave a toxic company for a different company in the same field, my previous employer can’t sue me.
It’s like peaceful reform is impossible.
Unfortunately, that’s the way things are looking right now. The Heritage Foundation is also threatening violence against the left if they don’t fall in line.
As if they won’t commit violence anyway. Domestic terrorists the lot. All of MAGA should be on no fly lists and banned from owning guns.
It’s just another bullet point in a half century long problem.
The FTC is an independent Federal anti-trust enforcement agency. After SCOTUS 1977 Continental TV v. GTE made the nuance of certain contact terms subjectively legal, allowing mergers likely in the interests of global competition, the FTC has been effectively neutered. The only significant action has been the breakup of the Bells in 1982 and some Microsoft anti-Netscape gibberish around 1999.
The FTC has effectively lost every significant case it’s brought since about 1970. Consumers haven’t had any significant protections since 1982, more than forty years ago.
Yeah, it does seem like enforcement is a futile exercise that’s permitted to happen for performative purpose while nothing gets done.
This sort of capture is pretty standard in other federal regulatory domains.
You either regulate pro industry or you won’t regulate at all. There is really no solution being proposed or really this sort of things is not even knowledged in these circles since people are making careers.
I’d like my digital persona and its data to be an EU member, please
Theyre going as fast as they can in a mad blitz trying to cause as much harm as possible before they get stopped
Except no one’s stopping em. Its like a sloth trying to stop a mosquito.
Almost like they don’t really want them stopped… just to look like they’re trying
Congress creates agency to assist them in their duties. Agency works as intended and does them. Court blocks them by saying “you were made to do X, not X.”
Fuck Texas, residents of the state can keep their fucking non-competes if they love them so fucking much… elsewhere let’s move ahead with this fucking awesome policy.
Fuck Texas. Anytime I hear people complain about “Democrat policies” around me, I just wish they’d move to their utopia in Florida, Texas, or any of the other “who’ll come up with the stupidest bullshit freedom-encroaching laws next” red state.
Workers leaving states like CA for Texas are like anti-vaxxers who think vaccines are stupid because they don’t know anyone with polio.
If our country survives for another couple decades, they’ll be so proud of themselves for “inventing” all the same worker protections they left behind. But not before experiencing their economic polio first hand.
If your company has PTO hours and you leave your job in Texas they don’t require you get paid out those hours so they are just lost. My coworker learned that. Absolutely need better worker protections across the board and Non-competes getting tossed is huge.
Honestly, if you’re choosing to live in Texas at this point you should expect to have very few personal rights.
… do you just expect everybody who lives there to pack up and leave? Even though their entire lives might be there and moving costs a ton?
They said “choosing,” which is the key word in their statement. Some people don’t have a choice like you said, but that’s really just a matter of the push/pull forces of migration at this point.
Yeah that’s fair. I don’t quite know why I read that the way I did, but I read the “choosing” as “lives there and isn’t actively attempting to move”.
Yea, I honestly don’t know what low income folks and kids can do - it’s such a regressive place but if you’re stuck there you just have to bear it and hope for change.
The original comment I was responding to was talking about PTO reclamation which is, sadly, a pretty white collar concern.
This wasn’t SCOTUS. They would agree, but this was not them.
These are coming down because of SCOTUS taking down Chevron. Now every rule must explicitly by made by the bills congress passes. They can no longer state an intent and hire experts to implement those intents vis rules.
We are heading into a Libertarians wet dream of government agencies being nearly Powerless thanks to our SCOTIS.
Chevron U.S.A., Inc. v. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc. created this monster. So yes the supreme court created this issue.
Rule of law is quickly being destroyed in the US. It’s a full-on coup of lawmaking ability
Congress blocks laws. Agencies can’t make laws. Judges can make laws. President is above the law.
